Player are listed under the team that they were originally on.
| Kernels | Highlanders | |
|---|---|---|
| Young, M. | >< | Madson, R. |
| KK #5 (Nix, J.) | >< | Johnson, J. |
| Upperdeckers | Marauders | |
| Wells, V. | >< | Street, H. |
| Keppinger, J. | >< | Ramirez, A. |
| Highlanders | Gamblers | |
| Beltre, A. | >< | Kazmir, S. |
| Bombers | Marauders | |
| Contreras, J. | >< | Matsuzaka, D. |
| Upperdeckers | Gamblers | |
| UP # 1 (Wieters, M.) | >< | TR # 1 (Bard, D.) |
| UP EX (Sanches, B.) | >< | TR # 3 (Fowler, D.) |
| Champions | Hitmen | |
| Doumit, R. | >< | NH # 6 Pick |
| Crosby, B. | >< | Young, D. |
| Kernels | Marauders | |
| KK # 2 (Porcello, R.) | >< | MP # 1 (Wells, R.) |
| Chamberlain, J. | >< | Masterson, J. |
| Bombers | Kernels | |
| Harris, B. | >< | Belliard, R. |
| Marauders | Bamm Beano | |
| Wainwright, A. | >< | Ramirez, H. |
| Hill, A. | >< | BB # 2 (Coghlan, C.) |
| Rivera, M. | >< | Uggla, D. |
| Lowell, M. | >< | BB #4 (Jepsen, K.) |
| Furcal, R. | >< | BB #5 (Cabrera, E.) |
| Griffey, K. | >< | Matsuzaka, D. |
| Garciaparra, N. | >< | Lidge, B. |
| Bombers | Kernels | |
| Soriano, A. | >< | Webb, B. |
| Champions | Hitmen | |
| CC # 1 Anderson, B.) | >< | NH # 1 (Beckham, G.) |
| CC # 2 (Rasmus, C.) | >< | Francoeur, J. |
| Bombers | Champions | |
| Okajima, H. | >< | Upton, B. |
| Marquis, J. | >< | Capps, M. |
| Matsuzaka, D. | >< | Young, D. |